Friday, June 5, 2015

[Yuba County] Grand jury report raises jail concerns


Yuba County has violated a court-ordered consent decree and its own job descriptions in the operation of the county jail, the grand jury says in its 2014-15 annual report released late last week.
The report on the jail focuses on a laundry list of issues ranging from overcrowding as a result of prisoner realignment to medical and mental health services provided to inmates. It notes the medical unit is "cramped" with only four work stations shared by a visiting doctor, mental health psychiatrist, dentist, licensed vocational nurses and medical assistants.
"Several members of the medical staff expressed dedication to their duties," the report states.
"They did, however, humorously deny liking the working conditions."
A portion of the report focuses on compliance with a 1978 consent decree stemming from a 1976 class-action lawsuit on behalf of jail inmates against the county. It notes the decree has not been updated in 36 years and that some requirements are no longer relevant.
But the report states the decree requires a registered nurse be at the jail at least 15 hours a week, though there hasn't been an RN on staff for three years.
"This is a violation of the consent decree," the report states. "The need for an RN is even more vital with the extended stays caused by realignment (shifting of prisoners from state prison to local jails)."
It also notes several medical assistants at the jail and a crisis counselor don't have proper credentials, in violation of county job classifications. And it states an executive assistant in medical services doesn't have a college degree, also in violation of county regulations.
"There is a disparity between the consent decree, the Yuba County Human Resources and the Yuba County Jail policies in regards to licensing/credentialing requirements," the report states.
It also states the fact the grand jury has not been provided with a copy of the decree is in itself a violation of the decree.
Yuba County Sheriff Steve Durfor said he would prefer to wait until he prepares a formal response to the grand jury to address details but said he disagrees with the report. Public agencies don't have to follow grand jury recommendations but are required to file formal responses within 60 days.
"What I find disappointing is the report is void of some very pertinent information that was provided to the grand jury prior to the issuing of the report," Durfor said. "On other findings, they are not accurate and without merit."
The jury notes medical and mental health issues are especially important with inmates staying longer at the jail through realignment.
"It became apparent during our investigation that the officers and other staff that serve this particular jail are challenged not only by the large numbers of inmates and their complicated needs, but the inadequacy of the facility itself," the jury states.
It recommends full-time licensed mental health counselor and registered nurse positions be filled, medical assistants be encouraged to obtain and maintain proper credentials, the existing medical unit be remodeled and that the inmate handbook contain a copy of the consent decree.
The jury also commended jail staff, medical unit employees and the substance abuse counselor for "dedication and enthusiasm."
In other matters, the grand jury recommends:
• Marysville Joint Unified School District address and eliminate what it calls a "hostile work environment" within the district. Suggested areas to address include "open communications without fear of reprisal" and "a simplified complaint system."
• Improved communications between the Marysville Joint Unified School District superintendent and the Board of Trustees and to properly provide the public with board meeting agendas.
• Development of a formal accident response plan for Yuba County Airport emergencies. It also recommends response drills and that the airport be included in multi-jurisdictional response exercises.
• Immediately moving ultra-light aircraft operations to a safer and more suitable location.
• Yuba County consider relocating emergency operations from the County Government Center to a location away from adjacent railroad lines, Highway 20 or a Marysville levee breach.
• Upgrading a surveillance system at Bi-County Juvenile Hall in Marysville, hiring additional staff and repairing insulation at the facilities recreation area.
• Sutter-Yuba Mosquito and Vector Control District "explore next-generation abatement techniques such as genetic modification of West Nile virus transmitting mosquitoes."
June 2, 2015
Appeal-Democrat
By Eric Vodden

Report on police militarization released by Monterey County civil grand jury


MONTEREY, Calif. —Increased militarization of local police departments is an emerging issue as more and more police forces acquire military-style weapons, vehicles, and tactics.
For its 2015 report, the Monterey County Civil Grand Jury decided to focus on how militarized our local police departments have become under the Department of Defense's 1033 Program.
"In Monterey County, two large armored MRAP vehicles have been obtained from the Department of Defense," the grand jury wrote in its report, released Monday. 
The Salinas Police Department acquired a mine resistant armored vehicle, as well as 30 M-16 rifles. Del Rey Oaks also received a mine resistant armored vehicle, which its officers described as a "rescue vehicle" when interviewed by KSBW. 
Seaside acquired a smaller, light armored vehicle, and 20 M-16 rifles.
The American Civil Liberties Union has raised red flags about SWAT teams using military equipment against civilians. 
The ACLU asserted, "American policing has become unnecessarily and dangerously militarized, in large part through federal programs that have armed state and local law enforcement agencies with the weapons and tactics of war, with almost no public discussion or oversight."
"Even though paramilitary policing in the form of SWAT teams was created to deal with emergency scenarios such as hostage or barricade situations, the use of SWAT to execute search warrants in drug investigations has become commonplace and made up the overwhelming majority of incidents the ACLU reviewed -- 79 percent of the incidents the ACLU studied involved the use of a SWAT team to search a person’s home, and more than 60 percent of the cases involved searches for drugs," the ACLU stated. 
The civil grand jury concluded, however, that all police departments in Monterey County were not over-stepping boundaries in how they battled crime. 
Key findings in the Monterey County report include:
- The Salinas Police Department currently deploys its MRAP vehicle on all SWAT operations, and during 2014 it was not used for any rescue, barricade, or hostage situations.
- The deployments of the Salinas Police Department’s SWAT team and the Monterey Peninsula Regional SRU appear reasonably limited to potentially dangerous situations.
- The Del Rey Oaks Police Department’s MRAP is not likely to be requested by other local 
agencies for anything but a rare prolonged active shooter situation or a catastrophic natural disaster.
- The problems noted in the American Civil Liberties Union’s 2014 report, in which they concluded that American policing has become "unnecessarily and dangerously militarized," do not appear to be present in the Monterey area police departments reviewed by the MCCGJ or in the Salinas Police Department," the grand jury wrote. 
June 2, 2015
KSBW The Central Coast
By Amy Larson

[San Diego County] Grand jury faults police evidence room


Report says security cameras, other measures, were lacking


The San Diego Police Department’s property and evidence storage facilities aren’t regularly audited and lack written procedures to determine when property should be kept or disposed, the county grand jury said in a report Monday.
The evidence rooms also lacked security cameras, the report said, although the department says it has added 16 since the grand jury inspection.
The jury, which serves a civic accountability function, said evidence rooms of the Sheriff’s Department and the El Cajon Police Department are better in many respects than San Diego police. Those departments have better security camera coverage and procedures for auditing the material, according to the report.
Among the conclusions by the panel was that there is poor communication between the department and the District Attorney and City Attorney about when to keep or dispose of evidence. The panel said this has led to property being retained longer than needed, such as after a case has closed.
As a result the department has had to rent storage space to keep the property, a cost to taxpayers that the panel said was unnecessary and could be eliminated with better procedures.
Other findings:
•       The room where weapons are stored is “in disarray and lacked security cameras.”
•       There are no security cameras in the property storage area either. Both El Cajon and the sheriff have security camera coverage, which is also a best practice recommended by a police training standards group.
•       There is no way of tracking who enters or leaves areas where safes are located. Keeping a record of who accesses safes is also recommended by the police standards group, the report said.
•       With no formal procedure in place on when to get rid of evidence a less formal system has developed. “Often, at the request of the property room manager, SDPD detectives decide when evidence in the property room can be disposed of or returned to its rightful owner.”
In a statement the department said that the property room is also undergoing a city audit, and the department has made contact with prosecutors to develop a reporting system for the timely review of evidence in cases.
The grand jury investigated the property room after media reports about how it is managed, how evidence is accounted for and tracked and how promptly evidence is returned to citizens or disposed of when it is no longer needed.
The grand jury inspected the main property room at the downtown San Diego police headquarters building. It is one of nine places where the department stores property and evidence, and the facilities are 95 percent full.
June 1, 2015
The San Diego Union-Tribune
By Greg Moran

[San Joaquin County] Grand Jury: City fixed problems


The San Joaquin County Grand Jury released the findings of a follow-up investigation into the city of Tracy that showed that city leaders properly addressed the deficiencies reported last year.
On June 9, the Grand Jury released a report about the city’s attempt to change the length of Runway 12/30 at Tracy Municipal Airport, 5749 S. Tracy Blvd. The jury found that the City Council acted on wrong information from the city staff that might have jeopardized federal grants and undermined the city’s credibility with citizens.
The Grand Jury investigation found that there was no proof of allegations of a secret and illegal business arrangement between the city and Surland Cos. LLC regarding the length of runway 12/30 and a $50,000 payment to the city made by Surland on behalf of the former airport fuel provider, Turlock Air. The jury recommended that the City Council instruct the city staff to make a comprehensive review of Federal Aviation Administration and state safety zone requirements.
The Grand Jury suggested that the council should adopt a policy requiring city staff members to disclose proposed substantial changes to any major developments in the city to avoid the perception of collusion. The panel also recommended that the city adopt a policy governing third-party payments for contractual obligations to the city — after reviewing a $50,000 payment made by Surland to cover money owed to the city by Turlock Air — to avoid the appearance of impropriety.
On Sept. 2, the City Council publicly agreed with the Grand Jury’s findings.
Monday, the Grand Jury released the results of a follow-up investigation, which concluded that, “acting on the earlier Grand Jury’s recommendations, those deficiencies have been addressed.”
Jury Foreman Ward Downs spoke Tuesday with the Tracy Press and congratulated the city on working with the panel.
“We’re just trying to get transparency,” Downs said of the report, adding that the Grand Jury believes in the value of following up for residents after an investigation. “We’re certainly the front of the train when it comes to doing follow-up. The Grand Jury system worked and City of Tracy definitely heard our comments.”
The panel specifically said that it reviewed the city’s responses and found no further need for action, mentioning that the city completed an FAA safety review according to a memo dated Dec. 29 and instituted a new procedure governing third-party check payments.
City Manager Troy Brown said the city was pleased with the findings from the follow-up investigation.
“We do what we say we’re going to do here,” Brown said. “The city has worked diligently to implement the recommendations of the Grand Jury and provide information relative to city procedures. It is my hopes that with this behind us, we can continue to move forward on important matters facing the city.”
June 1, 2015
Tracy Press
Press staff report

Thursday, June 4, 2015

[Ventura County] Grand Jury says county needs to improve bicycling safety

VENTURA, Calif. - The Ventura County Grand Jury released a report this week on bicycle safety in the region, saying the county should do more to create a safer cycling environment.

The civil investigative panel of 19 residents gathered information on bicycle safety and related laws from the Internet, newspapers, magazines and interviews with city and county officials, according to the report released Wednesday.

The grand jury found that in most bicycle deaths, the driver of the motor vehicle was at fault, and the number of fatalities might be reduced if all adults wore helmets.

Better education of the public about bicycle-related laws also is needed, the grand jury said. Some cities have received federal, state or other grant money to work with advisory committees or transportation agencies to educate residents about cycling conditions, the report stated.

“City councils of cities that do not already have a bicycle advisory commission or committee (should) establish one to advise on improving bicycle safety; developing and maintaining bicycle lanes, paths, trails and signage; and encouraging the use of bicycles,” the grand jury recommended.

The county Board of Supervisors and city officials also should work with law enforcement to increase enforcement of bicycle-related laws, the panel said.

Mike Stewart, a member of the Channel Islands Bicycle Club, said “education is always important” but it is difficult to get people to attend meetings or events. Instead, Stewart said, bicycle-safety rules for motorists should be emphasized more on written driver’s license exams.

Stewart said cyclists should be aware of what’s happening on the road and follow all laws, but motorists should give them a little extra room. A law that took effect in September requires drivers to stay at least 3 feet away from bicyclists.

“Common sense a lot of the time has to be applied here by a person driving the car,” Stewart said.

By: Megan Diskin
Ventura Star

Monday, June 1, 2015

Orange County animal shelter in 'utter disrepair,' grand jury report says

The 74-year-old Orange County animal shelter has fallen into "utter disrepair," creating health risks to both humans and critters, according to a new grand jury report.

The main structure, built with unreinforced brick and surrounded by "piecemeal placements of sheds, gazebos, lean-tos, trailers," and other portable units may not survive earthquakes, the report found.

When the facility first opened during World War II, it was intended to serve about 200,000 residents. But today, with 18 contract cities also depending on the county for animal care services, the coverage area includes roughly 2.1 million people, more than 10 times the original target.

The shelter, which sits next to the Theo Lacy Jail in Orange, is "overcrowded and unable to sustain" its urgent work of providing "compassionate care," said the report, released last week. It noted that structural changes made at the facility over the year could be in violation of building codes, threatening the county with legal liability.

Jurors slammed county leaders for failing to solve urgent problems, including cleanliness and sanitation.

For more than 20 years, the Board of Supervisors "has been keenly aware of the real and immediate need for a new shelter facility," and in 1995 set aside $5 million in seed money to build one, according to the grand jury's findings. Officials asked county executives to oversee the project but "to date, nothing substantive has been accomplished toward achievement of this task."

This report is "right on," says animal rights activist Rose Tingle, who lobbied supervisors to fix the problem. "These are third-world conditions" existing in affluent Orange County, she added, "but, really, no one wants to listen. They give you lip service but their action is to show inaction.

"I would like the county to get out of the animal shelter business," Tingle said. "They do not have the level of consciousness to be in it. What they have at the shelter is appalling. Animals deserve better. Their staff and the public deserve better."

Todd Spitzer, chairman of the Board of Supervisors, could not be reached for comment. To build new shelters, the grand jury suggests that officials fund a position, assigning someone to take charge of design and construction.

Meanwhile "every California county with a population exceeding 500,000 has more than one animal shelter facility," the report noted. "Orange County is the exception, having one shelter facility despite the geographic and demographic need for multiple shelters."


Jean Bland, a member of a South Orange County coalition for a new shelter, said: "I am so thrilled that the grand jury took a thorough look at this unimaginable situation. We've had reports issued in the past but this one is the most hard-hitting."

There are no standard or regularly scheduled inspections of the shelter, according to the report. The last inspection occurred in December 2008, when the California State Board of Veterinary Examiners came to the site, visiting only a vet clinic, rather than the entire facility.

A supervisor told the new grand jury that the county "is unable to inspect the roof of the main structure for fear of its collapse."

"If the county is afraid that the roof could fall in, why haven't they done anything about it?" Bland asked. "I know that the supervisors will continue to sit on it. They truly do not care, unless the voters make them care. Voters have to stand up and say, 'You have to do this or we never vote for you again.'"

anh.do@latimes.com
Twitter: @newsterrier