Thursday, August 15, 2019

[Riverside County] Report: At least $1 billion needed to buy Riverside County habitat land – and time’s running out

Grand Jury says meeting the goal poses “significant financial risk” to county.


It will take another $1 billion to $1.5 billion – far more than once publicly projected – to buy up enough land to protect endangered animals and plants in western Riverside County through a conservation plan that’s unlikely to be completed on time, according to a new report from the Riverside County Civil Grand Jury.
The report, released on June 26, also chides leaders of the Western Riverside County Regional Conservation Authority for lax oversight and dubious spending. Specifically, the report questions the wisdom of spending on lobbyists and outside contractors while not paying for park rangers and maintenance for land already conserved under the 15-year-old plan.
At least one expert not connected to the grand jury echoed the basic allegations in the report.
“The (Regional Conservation Authority) and its board members need to do their job and meet the conservation obligations they signed up for,” Ileene Anderson, a senior biologist at the Center for Biological Diversity, said in an emailed statement.
“The grand jury report reveals some very serious problems. Failing to address them endangers the plan itself, not to mention the nearly 150 species that desperately need protection in western Riverside County,” Anderson added. “Plants, animals and taxpayers deserve better.”
“Besides threatening the species they are to protect by not acquiring sufficient lands and money, the RCA is allowing the already protected lands like the wonderful San Jacinto Wildlife Area to become ‘islands’ surrounded by urbanization,” said George Hague, Sierra Club Moreno Valley Group conservation chair.
Charles Landry, executive director of the Conservation Authority, issued a written response to the grand jury’s allegations, saying his organization “appreciates the Grand Jury’s acknowledgement of the work our agency provides and the challenges we face in creating the County’s 500,000-acre reserve system while facilitating the rapid permitting of transportation projects (over $4 billion to date).”
Landry suggested the organization is aware of the funding shortfall: “We also appreciate (the grand jury’s) recognition of the substantial funds required to meet the plan’s acquisition goals for the next decade.”
The grand jury, a court-appointed panel of 19 citizens who are replaced annually, examines public agencies’ inner workings and suggests improvements. Its reports typically are released once a year, usually in late June.
Enacted in 2004, the Western Riverside County Multiple Species Habitat Conservation Plan is one of the biggest land conservation programs in the country, seeking to preserve a half-million acres by 2029. The goal is to protect 146 species of plants and animals – including creatures such as the endangered Stephen’s kangaroo rat and flora such as the San Diego ambrosia plant – while still allowing future development and infrastructure.
The conservation authority, an alliance of county government and 18 cities, plus a half-dozen regional and state agencies, oversees ongoing efforts to acquire land and maintain what’s already protected through the plan.
The grand jury suggested the agency’s leadership (the authority is overseen by a 23-member board consisting of the five county supervisors and elected officials from 18 cities) doesn’t understand the agency’s purpose. Board members, according to the report, “have a limited understanding of the (the authority’s) very complex requirements and obligations.”
When the plan was established, about 15 years ago, 347,000 acres of western Riverside County already were set aside. The goal was to use a combination of state and federal financing to buy up the remaining 153,000 acres. To date, less than half that land – about 61,000 acres – has been preserved.
Initially, officials projected the cost of acquiring land would run about $4,000 an acre, or roughly $61.2 million. But over the years, as property values have gone up – and with the imposition of guidelines calling for the preservation of so-called “criteria cells” to link sensitive stretches of land – the price has shot up to about $13,000 an acre.
Figuring in added price bumps over time, the new estimated price tag could run north of $1 billion, a number the grand jury described as “staggering.”
“This represents a significant financial risk to the County,” the grand jury wrote.
What’s more, the grand jury projects that the agency isn’t on a pace to acquire the property it needs in time to meet an original 25-year timeline. “The approval process and accompanying environmental reviews (to extend the timeline) would likely be arduous, time-consuming and possibly contentious.”
The authority’s board “has not acknowledged its inability to meet the current time table,” the report added.
The grand jury also found that there isn’t nearly enough money on hand to maintain land even if the agency could buy it up. As of now, according to the grand jury, there is about $5.8 million in an endowment to pay for future maintenance and oversight of habitat land; far less than the $70 million once projected as necessary. Among other things, the current budget lacks money for park rangers, the jury reported.
Without maintenance and rangers, the grand jury reports that the land already is being degraded by “fires and floods, as well as off-highway vehicles … and homeless encampments.” Such damage, the grand jury wrote, “will only increase in the future.”
The grand jury took the Conservation Authority to task for spending on “costly contracts” for various services, including unspecified lawyer’s bills and $200,000 a year for two federal lobbyists. “These costs drain the limited general funds, used to build up the endowment and other services.”
Plan funding was to come from fees connected to new housing and commercial properties and landfill services, as well as transportation taxes and grants, among other sources, the grand jury reported.
And, in 2005, development fees yielded more than $33 million for the plan. But the recession of 2007 and ’08, and slow economic growth that followed, caused those fees to drop to $10 million a year or less, the report read. Funding sources also were capped or eliminated, and money from landfill-tipping and infrastructure fees in recent years hasn’t matched even dwindling development fees, according to the grand jury.
A bill pending in Congress seeks to free up federal funding to buy more land by creating a wildlife refuge. The bill, HR 2956, is sponsored by Reps. Ken Calvert, R-Corona, Mark Takano, D-Riverside and Pete Aguilar, D-Redlands.
The plan’s funding issue “is not new, and has been an ongoing challenge since our inception,” Landry wrote.
“That’s why we are excited” about HR 2956.
July 3, 2019
The Press-Enterprise
By Jeff Horseman


Wednesday, August 14, 2019

[Santa Clara County] Santa Clara Governance Is Nothing Short Of Trump-Ian Political Theatre – Letter To The Editor

My following is in response to the Mayor and City Manager’s statements regarding the Grand Jury report. To reiterate what the Santa Clara City Manager said in her statement, “I cannot stay silent against these unwarranted and misinformed statements.” I whole heartedly agree with her. I can’t stand on the sidelines and watch this calamity.
Why can’t the city admit they were wrong? Instead, the Mayor and City Manager continue to spin and orchestrate the fallout with their own narrative, that is nothing short of Trump-ian ethics. While both the City Manager and Mayor state that transparency is a pillar of government and their administration, it may be time for a refresher in transparency 101.
“Everyone is wrong, it must all be fake news. The Grand Jury is wrong, the media must be wrong, and everything the city is guilty of is wrong.” This is what they believe and what they want the public and you to believe. The current Mayor and City Manager must have law degrees by knowing more than a Grand Jury, the media or community watchdogs on public records. Right now, the city is on full alert and doing PR damage control to take the spotlight off Santa Clara.
Admitting a shortcoming is a much stronger a response and more respectable than denial. These are not reforms, this is the classic delay, deny and deflect from real answers. It’s a “my way or the highway” or “scorched earth” policy that, in result, is toxic for Santa Clara and its residents. No collaboration, no outsiders, just insiders and a close-knit clique. City Hall’s tantrum response is absolutely distasteful that echoes the Trump White House.
This mentality played out this week in retaliation politics with a letter from the City Clerk that states his and the City Manager’s concerns on the use of a city logo that is in result is either homophobic or vindictive, you decide.
The letter dated June 18, the same day as the release of the Grand Jury report, states that my actions for producing 4 shirts for Pride month, using the city logo in a rainbow format was wrong. I had given the shirts to the City Manager and Mayor at a City Council meeting for recognizing Pride Month. The design on the shirt was the concept for Santa Clara’s participation in LGBTQ Pride Month and hopefully being able to participate together as a city in the Silicon Valley Pride Parade in August. I find the letter to be petty and doing nothing but playing politics.
Just like the faulty records compliance, Santa Clara is behind on the times in progressive social issues and technological advancements.  Our website is out of date and has garnered criticism, and is not easy to navigate versus those of other city cities. The Grand Jury findings are proof that the city is far behind in its practices. Santa Clara acts like it is still stuck in the 20th century, while the residents are living in the 21st century.
The Grand Jury couldn’t get the records they wanted for the initial investigation which led them to believe the lack of compliance with CPRA law was a major red flag and bigger issue…..and there is no if and or but’s about it in their report.
Special Interests:
I find it very interesting and insulting that the City Manager and Mayor call out my response and the Grand Jury report for being driven by “special interests.” Once again this is the hypocrisy we live within Santa Clara. Some sort of fantasyland of alternative facts. My former opponent, the Mayor, comes from those special interests and was funded by developers (check the 460s) in the last election.
I work as a contingent worker for a social media company and I struggle to survive here in the Bay Area like many other hardworking families. How is that a special interest? If anything …. it’s working class, far from the special interests claims. This is an example of classism and only ask for the Mayor and the City Manager to provide substantial proof of these “special interests” to back up their false claims.
The Mayor promised to get to the bottom of this, yet this sounds too familiar, like in 2016 where it was promised to pull back the curtain to expose BluePac. As of today, nearly 4 years later, nothing has been done about BluePac and nothing was ever found or resolved…only a dark money ordinance, which still can have candidates funded by special interests.
So, when the City Manager and Mayor continue to hang their hats on their transparency express train, they neglect the fact that they are being the complete opposite. The bullying and narcissistic approach has been a drain on our city employees. It is no wonder that I, and other residents, wonder why there is such a high turnover at City Hall, Something is broken, and these are just some examples of the fallout of bad governance.
Don’t get me wrong our city staff has to put up with a lot from large egos to state compliance issues. I commend those employees and give them lots of credit for putting up with the tough day to day operations — recently they delivered a solid budget report.
The City Manager said there is a cure, yet our methods of remedies are different. I believe that cure is a new Santa Clara government, by the people and for the people, not of special interests nor driven by truthful lies. The city continues to think they can line item the truth, or believe the truth can be adjusted… the truth has no temperature.
Deborah Bress, a community watchdog, has been blowing the whistle on the city records requests for over a decade, yet her whistle must have been a dog whistle because it fell on deaf ears for years.
Ms. Bress often says that the city can’t cherry-pick what they want you to see. She believes that all records should be inspectable by the public at any time and I strongly agree. That is real transparency with nothing to hide. The city has a track record of secrecy and I and others have vocalized it in the past which essentially debunks the claims the City Manager states.
We can’t let city officials get off the hook that easily for their incompetence. Yet, in Santa Clara, in past decade there have never been consequences or accountability. Always finger pointing or the blame game. Santa Clara’s civil problems, I fear, could lead one day to criminality in the future. Current actions at City Hall are reckless and uninformed, not the other way around.
I continue to fight for my city as much as I can. I push for real transparency and accountable democracy. The results of the Grand Jury report provided many of us with a breath of fresh air, that real reforms are coming and that this power struggle and game of thrones is coming to an end. This is what happens when officials fear change. All we know is all eyes are on our city now.
This situation in our hometown often brings to mind the film “Chinatown.” The 1974 classic summed it up nicely with the lines “Forget it Jake, its Chinatown”…. In this case, “Forget it folks, it’s Santa Clara.”
Only you and others can make the changes and prevent the same problems from happening down the road.
July 3, 2019
The Silicon Valley Voice
Letter from Anthony J. Becker


[Alameda County] With grand jury in rearview, Alameda begins work on charter reform

Despite a highly critical grand jury report last week that skewered Alameda City Hall and urged them to bolster its city charter with specific interference laws, Alameda officials have actually been working on the issue for more than six months.
The grand jury and an independent investigation by the city into allegations that Councilmember Jim Oddie and Malia Vella interfered in the city manager’s power to select a new fire chief both prescribed adding clarity to what is a flimsy charter provisions when it comes to a firewall between decision-making duties given to elected officials and the city manager.
Councilmember Tony Daysog said he could not comment on the report until the city offers its official response to the grand jury, but added, “If nothing else the events of the last two years underscore how fragile our democracy is, even in Alameda,” said Daysog.
Making changes to the charter, though, is a painstakingly long process, primarily since they must be made through a vote of the people. But even before the city hall scandal hit in late 2017, there has been talk of updating the charter for years.
In addition, to adding specificity to what an elected official can and cannot do when it comes to interference, while also detailing the consequences for violating the provision, the charter discussion in Alameda could result in significant changes to the way their leaders are elected.
Marilyn Ezzy Aschraft first act as mayor back in December 2018 was to form an ad-hoc committee to study potential changes to the charter. She tabbed Councilmembers John Knox White and Tony Daysog with leading the effort.
A pair of charter workshops last week hinted at some of the progress the ad-hoc committee has made in narrowing down potential charter reforms.
Among potential changes to the charter is switching from the current at-large election style to district elections. Doing so would involve the city council being tasked with drawing the lines for five new districts. Alameda has never used district elections in its history, according to the League of Women Voters.
Ranked-choice voting, the election system used by Oakland, Berkeley, and San Leandro to elected voters through a ranking system is also a possibility. Proponents of the system tout its ability to produce more congenial elections since the ranking system favors a consensus candidate and saves money by eliminating the need for a run-off election.
A proposal made during last year’s campaign by Knox White to rotate the mayor’s position among the five councilmembers is also on the table. The arrangement is typically seen in smaller cities like nearby Emeryville, which has a population of over 10,000. Alameda rotated its mayor prior to 1972.
A far more political charter reform and potential inflammatory one, at least for Alameda moderates and conservatives, is the proposed elimination of the city auditor and city treasurer as elected offices. The current holders of the office are viewed among conservatives as vocal counterweights to the firefighters union’s dominance in city politics.
Critics of the City Treasurer Kevin Kennedy and City Auditor Kevin Kearney say the position is vestige of the past and most of their duties have slowly been folded into the work of the city’s professional staff. Oakland and Berkeley is the only other cities in Alameda County that directly elects an auditor. Only three cities have treasurers. Albany is the only one to elect its treasurer, the others are appointed.
Some proposals, meanwhile, could avoid the trouble of travailing the ballot measure process. The city council could simply enacting them as ordinances, such as campaign ethics rules and campaign finance restrictions. The latter is non-existent in Alameda. Increasing council pay could also be enacted by the council, although the optics of elected officials giving themselves a raise is not positive, even with the extremely low pay they currently receive.
Alameda’s mayor has not received a pay increase since 1970 and earns an annual salary of just $3,600. By contrast, nearby San Leandro, which is roughly the same size as Alameda, earns $25,000 a year. Alameda councilmember’s have it even worse, earning $1,200 a year without a pay raise since 1977, according to the League of Women Voters. The low pay, critics fear, sidelines working people from running for offices and favors the well-to-do and retired people.
It’s conceivable the list of potential charter reforms will have to be whittled down further or risk ballot fatigue for voters,” said Daysog. “We’re here to gauge the temperature of voters.” The issue is not likely to come before voters until November 2020.
July 2, 2019
East Bay Citizen
By Steven Tavares


Monday, August 12, 2019

[Calaveras County] Report: county should leave Delta College district Taxpayers at risk for further cost with no benefits, concludes Grand Jury

Calaveras County residents could be on the hook for more taxes without any direct benefits, according to the recently released Grand Jury Report.
If the county remains part of the San Joaquin Delta Community College District (SJDCCD), more taxes could be paid into the Measure L Bond, which was supposed toward the construction of a Valley Springs campus, according to the report. Those plans were eventually scrapped by the Delta Board of Trustees five years after Measure L was passed in 2004.
Calaveras County is divided by two different college districts – the SJDCCD and the Yosemite Community College District (YCCD) – serving the northern and southern portions of the county, respectively. The 2018-2019 Grand Jury chose to investigate why minimal funds from the Measure L Bond have been spent on the educational infrastructure in Calaveras, and why a Foothills campus has not been pursued.
Measure L, which was worth $250 million when it was passed, is set to expire in 2029.
“The Bond Measure provided $250 million plus interest and earnings for urgent and critical facility needs as determined by the Board of Trustees of (SJDCCD),” the Grand Jury Report states. “Measure L specified the establishment of an education center in the Mother Lode/Foothills area. This statement is qualified by standard bond language, which entitled the Trustees the discretion to prioritize and/or eliminate bond projects. Five years after the Measure was approved, the Delta Board of Trustees terminated its plan for the Foothills facility.”
Instead, the report shows, Delta chose to build a campus in Mountain House, a community northwest of Tracy on the western edge of San Joaquin County. That project, originally estimated to cost $55 million, ballooned to $95 million.
This year’s Grand Jury recommends secession of Calaveras County from the Delta College District by Dec. 31 of this year. It also recommends aligning the entirety of the county with the Yosemite College District or partnering with another entity to be a “distance learning campus.”
This is not the first time a Grand Jury has recommended leaving the SJDCCD.
The 2013-2014 Grand Jury, as the result of a citizen complaint, published its investigation into why Delta did not follow through with language that suggested a campus would be built in Valley Springs. From that investigation, the Grand Jury “recommended that the (Calaveras County Board of Supervisors) support withdrawal from Delta and seek inclusion in Yosemite.”
The SJDCCD response to that year’s Grand Jury Report was defense of its decision to “remove the Foothills project, citing that the student population in the portion of Calaveras County that it serves would not support a campus in the county.”
According to this year’s report, the 2014 board of supervisors adopted a wait-and-see approach, stating, “At this time, the Board does not support implementing the recommended action to withdraw from (SJDCCD). The desire of the Board is also for Delta College District to expand and establish a Foothill area campus or education center as was described in the Measure L ballot materials.”
But withdrawing from the Delta district is not as simple as the Board of Supervisors voting on it. According to Calaveras County Office of Education (CCOE) Superintendent Scott Nanik, California Department of Education District Organization Handbook on transfer of territory for school districts must be adhered to. The state education code dictates that:
“Transfer of territory from one community college district to another is initiated by a petition signed by either at least 25% of the registered voters in the territory or a majority of the members of the governing board of each school and community college district affected.
“If the transfer involves a change of territory affecting less than 5% of the adult population of the school district for which the transfer is being made, the petition may be transmitted by the county superintendent directly to the county board of supervisors and is effective without further review. This procedure may not be used more than once every five years.
“The committee must analyze the petition and hold one or more public hearings. The governing board of the community college district to which the territory is to be transferred must consent to the transfer. If the committee approves the petition, it must transmit the petition and information thereon to the Board of Governors of the California Community Colleges for review.”
“With two community college districts in our area, it’s hard to create a momentum,” Nanik said. He’s not so quick to leave the SJDCCD, because there are benefits to both district connected to Calaveras County. “Yosemite has made efforts to serve the population, and it’s more in line with our geographic area. It’s more difficult with Delta.”
But, Nanik said, Delta has tried to keep the lines of communication open with the CCOE. Rather than secede from Delta, he feels it’s best to keep all options open.
“I think that the more options we have for our citizens, the better off we are,” Nanik said. “Right now we are offering two options that are in our backyard.”
Nanik went on to say that the CCOE is working to create a model where college courses can be offered online through a few different classrooms throughout the county with a handful of students attending each. That way the problem of internet connectivity would not be an issue for students wanting online classes.
A 2008-2009 San Joaquin County Grand Jury found that “the Delta College Board of Trustees were ill-prepared to handle the Measure L funds and made decisions which caused serious problems and wasted millions of dollars,” due to a lack of oversight.
That same investigation reported that the “demographic studies used by the Delta College District for facilities planning were questionable at best.”
More than half of Calaveras County voters in the SJDCCD voted against Measure L. But those voters only comprised 6.9% of all the voters in the college district which encompasses all of San Joaquin County (with the exception of the Ripon Unified School District) and portions of Alameda, Calaveras, Sacramento and Solano counties.
The 2018-2019 Grand Jury recommends leaving the college district as “there are no plans to spend funds in Calaveras County for the remaining life of the Bond.” It was reported that over the 25-year life of Measure L, Calaveras County taxpayers will have paid more than $10 million for facilities outside of the county.
Although the SJDCCD cited insufficient enrollment, the Grand Jury found there is a need for further educational opportunities, showing that the majority of high school graduates in the area go on to higher education. It was deemed necessary to have a campus for higher education due to a lack of public transportation to get students to the Stockton or Mountain House campuses. High-speed internet was also an issue, as online classes would not be accessible without it, something Calaveras County has struggled to implement for many years.
“The 2018-2019 (Grand Jury) has concluded that the time for inaction has passed, and it is imperative for the county to move forward to secede from the (SJDCCD),” the report stated. “If nothing is done, the county citizens could be obligated to pay for future community college bond measures that provide no direct benefit to the county in return.”
July 2, 2019
Calaveras Enterprise
By Marc Lutz


[Santa Barbara County] Grand Jury Investigates Cachuma Water Project

Few issues are more important to the residents of Santa Barbara County than Water. In reviewing prospects for the upcoming Contract for the Cachuma Project, due in 2020, the Santa Barbara County Grand Jury (Jury) recommends that the 1995 contract needs far more than revision. 
Its coverage is outdated and does not address the challenges of the future, especially the likely disruptions due to climate change. Its different technical terms can mean the same thing, and a single technical term can have several meanings. The Jury recommends revising outdated provisions every 5 years.
The Jury recommends that, unlike in the past, the County Water Agency and the 5 Water Districts should speak with one voice to the Bureau of Reclamation, especially in regard to the amounts of water to be diverted to the Districts each year. Regular meetings of their technical staffs could alleviate disagreements.
The Jury recommends that local agencies combine to create a website which covers the essentials about the Cachuma Project and gives links to more specialized material.
July 2, 2019
Edhat Santa Barbara
Source: Santa Barbara County Grand Jury


Sunday, August 11, 2019

[Santa Barbara County] Santa Barbara Grand Jury Reports on Jail Death

Accuses Sheriff’s Office of Obstructing Investigation


On the eve of the release of a Santa Barbara County Grand Jury report scrutinizing the jail suicide of 45-year-old Alexander Braid, Sheriff’s Office officials announced another inmate died by suicide while in custody. Joseph Rose, age 47, succumbed to self-inflicted injuries last Sunday at Cottage Hospital, five days after guards discovered him unconscious in the main jail building. Originally from Honolulu, Rose had been in custody for approximately a year and three months awaiting trial on charges of burglary and battery when he died. Sheriff’s officials declined to comment further, citing the ongoing investigation.
In its report on Braid’s suicide, the Grand Jury highlights potential gaps and deficiencies in jail booking protocols that may have contributed to his death. The report also accuses the Sheriff’s Office of actively impeding its investigation by delaying and ignoring requests for information. “The Jury’s role in this case was to investigate the circumstances of the death, determine the facts, and make recommendations with the goal of improving local government operations,” the report reads. “The Jury regrets that, for the most part, the Sheriff’s Office seemed more interested in obstructing than working cooperatively with the Jury toward that goal.”
On the afternoon of July 5, 2018, four Sheriff’s Office deputies arrested Braid outside his home in Goleta, the report says. He appeared drunk and was reportedly acting aggressively toward another resident in the house. Deputies, two of whom were still within their probationary period, handcuffed Braid and placed him in the rear seat of one of their patrol cars, where a dashboard camera showed him growing increasingly agitated. He complained he was thirsty and began violently slamming his head against the interior. “A family member who was present told the Jury they had important information about [Braid’s] mental health history but was not interviewed by deputies,” the report says.
In violation of their own procedures, deputies also failed to check Braid’s arrest record, the report claims, which would have shown he was arrested in December 2015 and engaged in “suicidal talk.” His behavior triggered an involuntary 5150 hold at the time and transport to Cottage Hospital for treatment.
On the way to the jail, Braid called out to God for help and continued smashing his head against the inside of the car, resulting in contusions to his forehead. Once inside the jail, Braid reportedly refused to answer questions from a nurse about his mental state and was escorted to a cell to “sleep it off,” the report continues. The Grand Jury asserts Braid should have been subjected to a more rigorous psychiatric evaluation, given his history, level of agitation, and self-harming behavior. Video shows Braid entering Cell C-9 at 7:10 p.m. At 7:35 p.m., a guard found him unconscious and radioed for help. At first, guards couldn’t find the cellblock’s emergency resuscitation equipment, and when they did, it didn’t work properly. Braid was declared dead at 8:02 p.m.
In his obituary, Braid’s family remembered him as “genuine, loving, humorous, and kindhearted.” A graduate of Santa Barbara High School, he worked as a salesman and enjoyed surfing, they said.
The Sheriff’s Office has 60 days to respond to the report. Spokesperson Kelly Hoover said the department takes the Grand Jury’s findings seriously and “will issue a detailed response well within the time frame, including correcting several inaccuracies.” She went on to say that over the years relatively few inmates have died by suicide in the County Jail. “To put it in perspective, approximately 17,000 inmates are admitted to the jail each year, yet since 2001 there have been four in-custody deaths as a result of suicide.” That figure includes Rose’s death last week, Hoover said.
July 2, 2019
Santa Barbara Independent
By Tyler Hayden


[Alameda County] 5 observations on the ALCO grand jury’s deferential view of law enforcement

1. Glorified Google search
The Alameda County grand jury involves civil, not criminal matters. The report released by the grand jury last week is not like its more high-profile criminal sibling. This isn’t the Mueller investigation, but an annual potpourri of investigations aimed at government transparency. Most people with better things to do, gloss over the difference. Nonetheless, the civil grand jury’s determinations in the past have carried immense weight within local government discourse. A negative finding can saddle shame on an entire government body for a number of years. An elected official’s adverse appearance in a civil grand jury report can render their re-election in serious doubt. Sadly, those days are over after three years of virtually worthless reports from the Alameda County grand jury. The dearth of any new information from these grand juries is further downgraded by the appearance of the individual reports being nothing more than glorified Google searches based on existing media reports and opinions extrapolated from scant facts. The risk today is that too much weight is now given to the grand jury’s findings. The document produced by this grand jury is shockingly substandard and raises serious questions as to why this body exists. For several years, grand jury reports have lacked direction and purpose. The grand jury has the power and duty to investigate individual complaints, but in most cases covered in this recent report, they choose to based their findings are assumptions and ascribed motives when they could have just interviewed witnesses. This choice to stifle its own power was prevalent in the grand jury’s investigation into alleged charter violations by Alameda Councilmembers Jim Oddie and Malia Vella.
2. Elected officials appearing to appear to do something wrong
In one section of the report, the grand jury noted former Alameda City Manager Jill Keimach, while recording a conversation between herself, Oddie and Vella, because she believed they were illegally violating Alameda’s charter prohibition on council interference, repeatedly mentioned feeling pressured by the two councilmembers. The grand jury, however, did not weigh the fact Keimach was the only person in the room who knew the conversation was being recorded. Are you pressuring me, Mr. Oddie? Say it louder into this voice recorder located in my right jacket pocket. Essentially, the grand jury purposely chose to overlook Keimach’s intention in recording the meeting was to gain evidence of extortion on the councilmember’s part. They also found no possible motive for Keimach to be untruthful. Same with Alameda Police Chief Paul Rolleri, who fingered Oddie as threatening Keimach’s job. But perhaps both have strident anti-union tendencies? Maybe other personal factors are involved? The same flimsy rush to add motives to Oddie and Vella, however, was used often by the grand jury, especially for Vella, which they accused of violating the charter, but never provided an specific reason in the report other than a wide-ranging pattern of actions. Furthermore, the grand jury declared the entire scandal was the impetus for a number of high-level city employees leaving Alameda for opportunities elsewhere. The grand jury based this assessment on what other people believed was the reason for the mini-exodus, instead of asking the former employees. Let’s be real. Four older Alamedans out of 19 grand jury members likely held sway over the Alameda portion of the report. Alameda is roughly five percent of all of Alameda County yet made up an disproportionate number of grand jury members. Only Oakland, with six grand jurors, had more. In addition, the grand jury report notes that 40 people issued complaints about the Alameda interference episode. That suggests a concerted effort by Alameda’s dwindling conservative flank to take out Oddie and Vella.
3. Old white people love the police
The prevailing opinion from this grand jury is that members of law enforcement are beyond reproach goes well past believing Alameda’s police chief–just because–but the single most notable part of this entire report. This grand jury made up of possibly 17 of 19 Caucasian seniors made no attempt to conceal their praise and view of the infallibility of local law enforcement. Take the Urban Shield screed that faults the Alameda County Board of Supervisor losing funding for the controversial emergency training and police-palooza in Pleasanton. The ultimate decision by the board earlier this years to pass on funding for Urban Shield was indeed confusing to onlookers. Several press reports got it completely wrong and even some county staff were flummoxed by the board’s initial action. But, by no means was there room to impugn the board’s decision as an instance of poorly-run government. It was a purely political decision made by the board that has festered for several years. The grand jury, however, discounted the concerns of the police accountability activists who believe Urban Shield fostered stereotypes against Muslims and ratcheted up a militaristic ethos at local police departments. Alameda and San Leandro have military-looking tanks within their arsenal, as does Fremont. The grand jury asserts the Board of Supervisors “mismanaged” the entire Urban Shield ad-hoc committee process and therefore, “resulted in the loss of essential regional emergency preparedness training, leaving county residents less safe.” Urban Shield opponents might counter the board’s decision actually made them more safe. The fact of the matter is the grand jury should have spread the blame around and included Alameda County Sheriff Gregory Ahern. His hubris, entitlement, and utter incompetence on this issue is the reason why Urban Shield no longer exists. But this would never fit into a worldview concocted over cheesecake in the kitchen of the Golden Girls. Among several recommendation made by the board to Ahern was to simply rebrand the Urban Shield name. Ahern dug in and then took his ball home. The big takeaway politically from the Urban Shield decision is that the Board of Supervisors finally stood up to Ahern’s inelegant bullying tactics. This report in several instances represents a call for backup by Ahern to the ultimate arbiter of this grand jury report.
4. Death at Santa Rita Jail. Seems fine, says grand jury
Were some scores settled in this grand jury? Looks like. Alameda County District Attorney Nancy O’Malley technically oversees the grand jury process. One of her lieutenants, Assistant District Attorney Ross Warren is in charge of the grand jury. Warren has long ties to Rep. Eric Swalwell’s congressional campaigns since 2011. There’s a definite thread that connects Ahern, O’Malley, Swalwell, Alameda County Supervisor Scott Haggerty in East County’s undercurrent of moderate to right wing politics and praise for law enforcement. In addition to the Alameda councilmembers report, Urban Shield, pro-law enforcement reports in this years grand jury show up in an investigation of Santa Rita Jail’s intake procedures. The grand jury painted a positive view of the situation even though several incidents at the jail had caused serious concern, including the death of a female inmate and a pregnant women who gave birth while alone in a cell. While the grand jury report was presumably being finalized, another death occurred inside the jail this month. Yet, the grand jury concluded, “no significant issues were identified” with the jail’s intake, release and grievance process. The disconnect between facts and conclusion is likely because the grand jury only interviewed prison management and not inmates.
5. Potential end-run at Bonta for DA in 2022?
The cynical view would be to perceive this report as a partisan attack on opponents of local police. To use the grand jury’s own methodology, there is a clear and repeated pattern in this report for giving cover to police. The Urban Shield report favors Ahern and attempts to punish the Alameda County Board of Supervisors over a purely political issue. Santa Rita Jail’s problems get glossed over with an intensely narrow investigation into intake procedures. So, Ahern is covered, what about O’Malley? There is buzz in Alameda County that Assemblymember Rob Bonta’s next move after his 12-year term in the Assembly nears in 2024 that he’s interested in pursuing a career track that flows through the Alameda County District Attorney’s office. Maybe O’Malley retires before then? In that case, maybe she hands off the seat to a underling in order to block Bonta’s path? Maybe it’s Swalwell? In Alameda, where Bonta got its start, some progressives view this report as an attack on Oddie, Bonta’s long-time right-hand man (Vella is also close to Bonta). The charge is not new either. Last October, O’Malley chose to release her report on Alameda City Council interference just weeks before Oddie’s council election. To Oddie’s supporters, the “October Surprise” appeared to be O’Malley’s own version of James Comey undermining Hillary Clinton’s presidential campaign at the last minute.
July 2, 2019
East Bay Citizen
By Steven Taveras


Sutter County Fire faces dire situation, report says

Area schools and jail pose concerns, grand jury reports


After taking a year off for undisclosed reasons, the Sutter County Grand Jury released a report of its findings from its investigations in 2018-2019. This year’s report covers what’s described as a dire situation facing one Sutter County Fire Department service area, needed improvements at area schools, and concerns over the county’s jail facility and sheriff’s office.
The report was submitted to and approved by Sutter County Superior Court Judge Susan E. Green at the end of May and filed by the court on June 28. To view the document, go to https://www.suttercourts.com/general-info/grand-jury/reports.
Fire Department
Grand jury members highlighted the fact that Sutter County Fire Department, County Service Area F (CSA-F) – a 254-square-mile unincorporated area located just north and south of Yuba City – is facing dire challenges due to shortfalls in revenue and staffing, in addition to aging and failing emergency vehicles.
The service area has been the subject of past grand jury reports over concerns of staffing, renovations and installation of safety equipment. The CSA-F was formed in 1996 when the Live Oak Fire Department, Oswald-Tudor Fire Department and the Sutter Fire Department were consolidated. 
“CSA-F is in dire straits and the citizens of Sutter County need to be informed immediately. To prevent loss of life and future injuries, in accordance with National Fire Protection Agency 1710 guidance, staffing, equipment and structural issues need to be resolved. CSA-F is dangerously understaffed and alarmingly underfunded,” the report stated. 
The grand jury found that a Special Fire Tax for the district – one of three primary funding sources – was established in 1997 without an inflation index, resulting in the current situation where annual expenditures are surpassing recurring revenue. Because of a lack of funding, staff levels have been compromised, resulting in safety risks for fire personnel and citizens, and volunteers are becoming harder and harder to find. 
Firefighter injuries have also resulted in significant increases in workers compensation claims over recent years – costs in 2015 were $64,347 compared to the last fiscal year’s estimate of $275,171, or an increase of 328 percent. 
In addition to aging infrastructure, the Oswald-Tudor station needs an extensive remodel, which includes an extension of the building bays to accommodate newer equipment and a third exhaust ventilation system.
The grand jury recommended supervisors reassess the service area’s revenue stream and special fire tax by the end of the year and consider adding it to the county’s general fund. Other recommendations included the county forgiving the remaining balance of a loan to construct a fire station; and for the district to address its staffing and safety issues. 
Schools
The 2016-2017 grand jury report observed areas at several schools within the Yuba City Unified School District in need of repair, including roof leaks, exposed wood and cracks in pavement. This year’s group went back to follow up and found that most of the findings had been resolved at the schools, which included Andros Karperos Elementary School, Barry Elementary School, Gray Avenue Middle School, Park Avenue Elementary School, Riverbend Elementary School and River Valley High School. 
However, the recent report found that Andros Karperos has a roof leak in the gym and that removal of gutters from the school’s modular buildings has caused water to pool into puddles behind the building and has damaged the eaves. Jurors noted the school needed cleaning as well. While at Barry Elementary School, faculty members raised concerns over the number of tractor-trailers utilizing Barry Road to access Highway 99. Also, the grand jury found that Gray Avenue is still in need of a gym. 
They recommended Andros Karperos replace its gym roof within one year and reinstall the gutters with gutter screens before the start of the school year. They recommended the school’s staff come up with a plan to maintain cleanliness on the campus as well; that a traffic safety analysis be conducted on Barry Road by the start of the school year and that Gray Avenue add a new gym to its project list within six months. 
Grand jury members also toured Bridge Street Elementary School, where they noted safety concerns – issues with a street crossing on a heavily traveled Bridge Street, and a potential issue with the lack of railing along the steps leading down to the library. 
They recommended the school district reassess the inadequate parking and pick-up/drop-off area at the school, to conduct a study to find an additional method to cross Bridge Street safely and to install additional railing on the steps leading to the library by the end of the year.
Jail/sheriff’s office
Grand juries are required to look into the condition and management of a public detention facility annually if one is located within its jurisdiction. The Sutter County grand jury found that improvements to the county’s jail and a change to contract health care are resulting in improvements for both housing and medical care of local inmates. That being said, they also highlighted some areas of concern regarding officer and inmate safety and the educational classes provided to the inmates. 
The grand jury found that one of the classes provided to inmates to help them obtain their GED currently does not have an instructor, meaning it is not being offered at the time the report was being worked on. They also observed a lack of designated classroom space for inmates.
Another area of concern raised by the grand jury was with an area at the facility where inmates are brought into and out of the jail, which is unsecured and accessible to the public.
They recommended the county and the sheriff’s department hire an instructor for the GED class, find and dedicate additional classroom space, build a secured fence between the sheriff’s office and the jail facility and install an automatic gate at the entrance of one vulnerable point by the beginning of 2020. 
In addition to touring the jail, the grand jury inspected the sheriff’s office. 
They raised concerns about the storage and handling of evidence and the outdated computer system that is being used to track evidence, in addition to a lack of secured parking for deputies and personnel.
The sheriff’s department has recently undergone construction upgrades that have resulted in the elimination of adequate storage space for property and evidence. 
Because the main evidence room has exceeded its available space, the department is utilizing storage containers outside, which do not have the electronic safety measures in place to document when records are viewed and by whom. 
The grand jury also noted that the department’s Chain of Command had not been trained on evidence unit procedures, which could lead to a backlog of untagged evidence or evidence being lost. That issue is compounded by the fact that the department’s computers and software system are outdated. 
Their recommendations included expanding or relocating the evidence room to meet professional standards; having property officers and management attend classes about maintaining those standards; implement auditing practices to better track evidence; to hire an independent auditing agency annually; upgrade computer system and evidence tracking software; and provide secured, designated parking for department employees.
July 2, 2019
Appeal-Democrat
By Jake Abbott


Saturday, August 10, 2019

[Madera County] Grand Jury Report: Finds unethical practices & intimidation by Madera mayor and council members during meetings

A grand jury report about the inner workings of the Madera City Council and it’s finances paints a concerning unethical picture.
The grand jury states it began its initial investigation after salaries were increased for department heads in the city of Madera.
At the same time, residents had their water rates increased.
So the grand jury was trying to determine if there was a connection.
The grand jury says after attending several council meetings, it turned its attention to the mayor and the city council.
The eight page grand jury report states Madera city administrators and elected leaders don’t have a written code of ethics to follow.
It states they have not attended any ethical training.
The report says city administrators and elected officials are doing personal business with the city as private individuals, which the grand jury found is a direct conflict of interest.
But more importantly, the grand jury found the city has a lack of transparency and even intimidation towards residents who speak before the council.
The report says agendas for council meetings are difficult to understand, and the public doesn’t know how to access them.
“We are taking the report very seriously,” says Madera City Manager Arnoldo Rodriguez.
Rodriguez has only been in office since December of 2018.
Rodriguez says, “My goal at the end of the day is to assure the people that their tax dollars are being properly allocated, that the decision making process is being done in public. There are no backroom deals happening here at the City of Madera.”
Rodriguez says city leaders will be going through ethics training and changes are being made to the agenda process.
He says agendas will be posted online in a timely manner and on all social media platforms. They will also not be written in technical terms.
Rodriguez says, “So they can pick up a report and understand what it says. So they have a comfort level knowing that tax dollars are being spent properly.”
But what about the grand jury finding elected leaders are doing personal business with the city of Madera?
Rodriguez says new policies will implemented.
Rodriguez says, “If those things have occurred we are going to make sure they don’t reoccur.”
CBS47 contacted the District Attorney of Madera County, Sally Moreno.
She said her staff is looking into the grand jury report to see if any criminal charges needed to filed.
July 2, 2019
YourCentralValley.com
By Eric Rosales


[Shasta County] Shasta Grand Jury report focuses on CodeRED system flaws

Redding, Calif. — The Shasta County Grand Jury published its 2018/2019 findings and designated the CodeRED system as it's biggest concern.
The 50 page document reads, "Our primary concern is that CodeRED is underutilized."
KRCR asked Shasta County Undersheriff Eric Magrini why this is just now becoming a concern.
" So we've always had a plan," said Magrini, "for example, in the inner mountain areas of Shasta County we have evacuation plans with Cal Fire but to put it simply, fires are faster, they are more intense, and they are more dangerous than in years past."
Another issue with sending out warnings is the switch from land lines to cell phones.
"Is there anyway at all that everyone can be informed even without signing up. There's no system that does that?"
"There's no system that [warns everyone without a sign up process] because the information we get from the phone companies is only as good as what is being provided to us," said Magrini. "People move frequently and change their number. The information we have is only what we can gather from people who register or from what we get from the phone companies for the land lines. So, this really puts the burden back on the people to be responsible and register for this service."
The grand jury report done in early 2019 reads "less than half the households in Shasta County are registered with CodeRED". Magrini says that number has increased since the report was done.
Which is why the grand jury is recommending more effort go into signing people up.
It also recommends an easier way to sign up.
Magrini says a governing board that oversees SHASCOM will look at the report as well and formulate a response to each of the concerns."
July 2, 2019
KRCR News
By Julia Avery