Sunday, August 18, 2019

[Ventura County] Grand jury calls for uniform policy on drug drop-off bins

Some are easy to access, others not so much


Having examined the policies and practices of local law enforcement agencies in regard to prescription drug and needle disposal, the Ventura County civil grand jury is recommending the Board of Supervisors develop a new, uniform program throughout the county.
After visiting all Ventura County Sheriff’s Office stations and the county’s five police departments, the grand jury found inconsistencies from station to station, with some having requirements for use of drug disposal bins and some having no disposal bin at all.
In Ojai, the bin was moved from the lobby and now requires assistance to access it. The Oxnard Police Department requires proof of residency to use its disposal bin, and the Simi Valley Police Department requires an appointment to drop off medicine.
Santa Paula and Ventura police departments have no drug disposal bins.
Of all the stations surveyed, only Hueneme Police Department had a “sharps” drop-off bin. Sharps consist of hypodermic needles, pen needles, intravenous needles, lancets and other devices that are used to break the skin of people and animals.
The issue is important, the jury found, because research over the past decade indicates that both prescription and over-the-counter medications require secure disposal to prevent accidental poisonings as well as land and water pollution.
Additionally, there is growing research to demonstrate that unsecured drugs and a lack of safe disposal options are partly to blame for the opioid crisis in the nation, the jury said in a report written last month.
It also said unsafe disposal of sharps can result in accidental infection or injury.
The 19-member investigative body took up the issue after reading in the Acorn about the case of a Ventura County sheriff’s deputy who was caught on video taking medication from the Thousand Oaks Police station’s drug drop-off box. The deputy, who is no longer employed by the sheriff’s office, was arrested in June 2016 and charged with petty theft and two counts of possessing a controlled substance.
He has yet to be tried.
In addition to establishing a countywide policy, the grand jury recommended all law enforcement agencies improve their public outreach regarding drug and sharps disposal and that the county’s animal services agency be included in developing and implementing new drug programs, as animal medications may be disposed of in the bins as well.
While the jury, which serves as a “watchdog” by investigating and reporting on the affairs of local government, has no enforcement power, it can compel a response from public agencies, which it then makes public.
The jury is requiring a response from each of the county’s cities, the sheriff’s office and the Board of Supervisors, and is requesting a response from the county’s behavioral health and animal services departments.
The agencies have 60 or 90 days, depending on type of organization, in which to respond.
July 5, 2019
Moorpark Acorn
By Becca Whitnall


[Santa Clara County] Milestones: If The Shoe Fits

Blog note: this opinion piece references a grand jury report.
The Weekly has served Santa Clara by one name or another continuously for over 150 years. The current ownership is perhaps one of the longest runs ever and, with sincere thanks to the community and our dedicated staff, we are still here reporting the news.
There appear to be a few City elected officials and staff members that find our publication something less than a newspaper. Which is surprising when you consider we are the same newspaper that former City Councils have voted as the official publication in the City.
We have not changed our policy or philosophy to satisfy or pacify elected or appointed officials, who are given voter approval to run our City. Since we haven’t changed, it must be others who have changed.
While The Weekly has focused on school activities, charities, and local events, politics have become a most controversial and absorbing topic. The transition of City leadership has changed with the advent of Mayor Lisa Gillmor and her three joined-at-the-hip supporters: Council Members Debi Davis, Teresa O’Neill and Kathy Watanabe. These three give the Mayor complete support without objection, question or opposition. Together, they have created a Council without checks and balances.
The Mayor and her team have effectively and systematically eliminated most every major long-term staff leader in our City. These include our prior City Manager, City Attorney, Finance Director, City Clerk, an all-out failed campaign to eliminate Police Chief Mike Sellers and the removal of a host of department heads. In short, her opposition is gone.
With the buying of her hired gun, City Manager Deanna Santana with a $700,000 package, Mayor Gillmor has ruled Santa Clara with little opposition. The only exception has been The Weekly. Thanks to our long-term Editor Angie Tolliver, who has diligently insisted our entire staff report the facts as they happen.
The recent report by the Grand Jury was completed after months of investigation. They reported the brutal facts about Santa Clara recordkeeping and the slow or non-responsive public record requests.
In a letter to the public, Deanna Santana brushed off the Grand Jury criticism like a piece of lint on a pricey black dress. While she expounded on the many changes the City was taking to make positive headway, she essentially blamed prior administrations and employees.
However, under the 25-year leadership of former City Manager Jennifer Sparacino and a decade with City Clerk Rod Diridon Jr, Santa Clara did not have these problems and complaints.
Santana has a well-established history in camouflaging issues. She was accused several times in Oakland of attempting to change documents and reports to her own liking.
Now, her “skills” have been brought to Santa Clara, where she can write pages of flowery prose to the public, designed to cover up the reality of a City gone south.
She blames The Weekly for being critical, saying our criticism is unfounded.
Friends, we don’t make up the facts, we just observe and report them.
This is a simple case and…the shoe seems to fit.
July 4, 2019
The Silicon Valley Voice
By Miles H. Barber


[Yuba County] Immigrant detainees begin hunger strike in Yuba County jail for improved conditions

Blog note: this article references a grand jury report about conditions in the jail.
At least 16 people detained by federal immigration authorities in the Yuba County jail have refused food for four days in the facility’s third hunger strike in 10 months.
The immigration detainees, who are mixed in with other inmates at the Marysville jail, are demanding newer facilities, better medical attention, and follow-through on promises to improve conditions. And they say they don’t want to be treated as “criminals” like the other inmates in the jail.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement is currently detaining nearly 200 people in the facility, said Leslie Carbah, a spokeswoman for the Yuba County Sheriff’s Department.
On Wednesday morning, activists from the Sacramento Immigration Coalition and other advocacy groups rallied outside the jail-courthouse complex in support of the strikers. They spoke in both English and Spanish and were critical of the jail’s and ICE’s policies toward the detainees. Joe Engle, a representative from the Sacramento Immigration Coalition, read a statement from an unnamed detainee inside the jail who said conditions were substandard.
“I’ve been in Yuba County jail for 12 months now. When I arrived, the living conditions were inhumane and they still are,” the detainee wrote. “There are cells that have no water, the lights are not working ... we are being treated not as ICE [detainees], but as criminals.”
Other complaints included cockroach-infested rooms and insufficient time out of cells.
Officially, a hunger strike begins when detainees have refused food for 72 hours, or nine meals, according to Carbah. However, they often still eat commissary food — small snacks like chips or ramen that they must pay for. But ICE’s guidelines for dealing with hunger strikes instruct facility administrators to remove all commissary or vending machine food from the striker’s room.
Rhonda Rios Kravitz, an advocate with the Sacramento Immigration Coalition, says this happened during the last strike in February. She also said that as of Wednesday late afternoon, strikers were moved to H pod, which she said is the oldest and dirtiest part of the building, which at least one Yuba County grand jury report called a “dungeon.” Jail officials could not be reached Thursday for comment.
ICE detainees make up about half of the jail’s residents. As of 2014, 220 of 433 total beds in the facility belong to ICE, which pays the jail $97.39 per day for each detainee. With an average detainee population hovering between 170 and 190, the operation brings in almost $6.5 million a year for the jail.
Paul Prince, a spokesperson for ICE in Northern California, said that 16 of the immigration detainees are participating in the hunger strike. By late Wednesday afternoon, Rios Kravitz said the number was down to 14.
The last hunger strike at the facility happened in February 2019, and ended after a few concessions were made by the jail. According to Casbah, the detainees were given their own exercise yard space separate from criminal inmates. Detainees and criminal inmates are currently housed in the same jail, but while inmates wear orange, detainees wear red.
The Yuba County Jail Facility has been open since the mid-’90s and has consistently earned “deficiencies,” or failures to meet ICE standards in areas like access to legal materials, use of force, and sexual abuse and assault prevention and intervention. In 2014, for example, the review commission found 14 deficiencies in the facility management.
Yuba County has been awarded $20 million by the state to build new adult correctional facilities, but construction has not started yet.
In a speech at the Wednesday event, Rios Kravitz demanded immediate changes to the system, including opening up the facility for inspections by an outside ombudsman and making public all records of use of force, solitary confinement, hunger strikes and suicide attempts.
“ICE has made it excessively difficult as to access how it and its contractors treat the people in its custody,” she said.
For detainees, little progress has been made on their previous demands. Carbah, the county sheriff’s spokeswoman, said that potential changes are limited by a consent decree, or a legal settlement between the jail and its inmates, which has been in effect since 1979.
“We have started this third hunger strike because we are tired of empty promises,” said the unnamed detainee in the statement. “We understand that we might not see any of these changes happen while we are here, but we’re willing to make this sacrifice to have our voices be heard and to make a dent in the system that is crooked.”
July 4, 2019
Sacramento Bee
By Elliot Wailoo


Saturday, August 17, 2019

[San Joaquin County] Tracy City Council far from consensus on grand jury findings

The Tracy City Council may come up with a single response to the grand jury’s critique of Tracy city politics, but Tuesday night’s discussion on the matter shows that the council is a long way from having a unified voice.
City Manager Jenny Haruyama told the council at the start of the 2½-hour discussion that the San Joaquin County Civil Grand Jury’s report had 15 findings and six recommendations for the council. On each finding, the council voted to “agree,” “disagree” or “disagree partially” with the grand jury.
On only two of those 15 findings did the council agree unanimously with the grand jury. The council also agreed with nine more of the findings, but with a 3-2 split on five of those votes as council members Nancy Young, Rhodesia Ransom and Dan Arriola voted to agree with the grand jury and Mayor Robert Rickman and Councilwoman Veronica Vargas dissented.
While the council was far from consensus on the grand jury’s findings, it did unanimously agree to accept its six recommendations to guide the council in the future. At the end of the discussion, Haruyama told the council that her staff would return at the July 16 meeting with a plan to implement the six recommendations.
The council heard from the public at the start of the discussion, and some of the people from the 19-member grand jury were in the audience. Among them was Terri Rocha, who addressed the council members at the end of the meeting. She stood behind the grand jury’s findings after the council’s discussion and the series of split votes.
“We on the grand jury have evidence of everything,” she told the council. “I would love to release that, but it’s not something that I can do.
“It’s obvious to me that … a lot of the council members seem to get what the grand jury said. Some are still in denial, because you’re part of the problem. I wish the council good in the future. I just hope the citizens of Tracy wake up.”
The 3-2 split was prominent on the matters regarding council ethics, with the council majority of Young, Ransom and Arriola agreeing that failure to establish an ethics policy reflected the council members’ inability to work together and that ethical behavior had been a low priority for the council.
Rickman took issue with the grand jury’s statement that “petty bickering” impaired the council’s ability to work for the public’s interests.
“If you want to take a better look at it, you can look our state of the city,” Rickman said. “This is what we’ve accomplished in the past two years, and no other council has even come close to accomplishing what we’ve accomplished.”
He then read a list of economic development milestones, as well as progress on city planning practices, transportation issues, city amenities, revenue increases, and marketing of the city to encourage new businesses and jobs.
“I’m just going to say a little bit more here. I have like eight pages of this,” Rickman said. He went on for more than 7 minutes before Ransom interrupted him.
“I think we all get the point that you disagree with the finding,” Ransom said, “but is this in accordance with what we’re supposed to be doing on this agenda item?”
Rickman replied: “These are just some of the examples. These are not even all of them.” He cited 24 straight months of economic growth.
“So when I disagree that it diminished our ability to conduct public business, my God, there’s no city that compares to us, how fast we’re moving,” Rickman said.
Young agreed that the city had made progress over the past two years but said that the core of the matter was in the detailed wording of the grand jury’s finding. The council spent a big part of the 2½-hour discussion talking about how the findings were phrased.
Young pointed out that where the grand jury says “the petty bickering … has diminished their ability to effectively conduct the public’s business,” it should have emphasized efficiency rather than effectiveness.
“I think ‘efficiently’ versus ‘effectively’ would probably be more relevant, because we did get things done, however there are things that we could have gotten done in lesser time frame,” Young said.
Arriola agreed with Young and again zeroed in on specific language.
“My focus on this is ‘diminished,’ and the fact of the matter is, what this finding is saying is that there was some negative behavior between council members that diminished the ability to effectively conduct public business,” he said. “I very much do commend the prior council on what they accomplished. I really do, but when we look at this, what it says is that the negativity diminished it. Without that negativity it would have enhanced it. It would have been better.”
The two unanimous votes came on the findings that the lack of an ethics policy had hindered the council in the past and that a new ethics policy would hold council members accountable in the future.
The council then unanimously agreed on recommendations that an ethics policy and “rules of behavior” be adopted by Oct. 31, as well as a recommendation that council members not allow personal differences to interfere with city business.
The council disagreed partially, again on split votes, on findings regarding the appointment of new council members — and then unanimously endorsed a grand jury recommendation that would give priority to the third-highest vote-getter in the event of a council vacancy following an election.
The 3-2 split, with Young, Ransom and Arriola in the majority and Rickman and Vargas in the minority, came up again on the matter of staff resignations and terminations. The majority agreed with grand jury findings that instability among high-ranking city staff caused anxiety among upper management in the city, and contributed to the public’s mistrust of the council and the belief that “power politics” on the council was behind staff turnover.
The council did agree with the grand jury’s recommendation that a 4-1 super majority be required to fire the city manager or city attorney, the only two staff positions hired by the council. All other upper management personnel are hired by the city manager.
Regarding council members “intruding into the responsibilities of city staff,” the council agreed with the grand jury’s findings, but Vargas said she would abstain from those votes.
“I really have no context on this,” Vargas said. “To me, I’m not aware of these allegations. For me it looks like a lot of assumptions.”
The council agreed unanimously that the city needs a policy outlining “sanctions or censure” for council members who try to give direction to city staff members without working through the full council and city manager.
July 4, 2019
Tracy Press
By Bob Brownne


[Humboldt County] Transitional Housing Project Moves Forward, Grand Jury Report Underscores Need 

Local philanthropist Betty Chinn plans to erect a small transitional housing village out of modular trailers donated by PG&E that have been lying dormant for months on the city-owned Crowley property on the south end of town.
PG&E donated the 11 trailers — which it had been using as administrative offices at the Humboldt Bay Power Plant — to Chinn back in September of 2017 and she planned to convert them into small apartments that people could use to build up rental histories for two years before finding permanent housing. But the plan had been waylaid in May of 2018 by threats of litigation from the owners of Pierson Building Center, which expressed concerns about impacts of the project and warned that the city wasn't following proper process.
"We applaud the city for trying to help those truly in need that are looking to make a better life for themselves," the letter said. "With that said, the businesses on South Broadway are at the breaking point due to the large populations of homeless, transient individuals, many of whom have mental issues and or drug abuse problems in our area. Increasingly, they frequent and prey upon the open door policy of retail businesses, attempting to steal merchandise on a regular basis and frequently becoming belligerent and or threatening in their behavior when confronted."
The city abruptly pulled an item from the city council's agenda that would have amended the property's zoning to make way for the project and then began researching other potential sites, seemingly to little success. Chinn said she started to think it wasn't going to work out and seriously considered an offer to sell the trailers for money she could use to fund her foundation's other endeavors, which include a day center, a family shelter and a children's after-care program.
Then, in April, the hardware store's owner Bill Pierson sent the city a letter indicating he'd had a change of heart, thanks in a large part to a conversation he'd had with Police Chief Steve Watson, during which the chief detailed Chinn's good work with Betty's Blue Angel Village, a makeshift shelter village crafted out of converted shipping containers that houses about 40 people.
"Chief Watson assured me that Betty Chinn runs a tight ship and that any facility that she is in charge of will be operated in the best way possible," Pierson wrote, adding that Watson was sympathetic that the store already faces a "deterioration in the local business environment." "He said that the presence of Betty's facility could actually improve the situation we are currently faced with by focusing additional services into our area."
As a result, Pierson said that not only was he "changing (his) position of opposing the project," but he was also pledging to personally donate $10,000 to Chinn "to help ensure the success of the project."
Because the proposed project is slated to sit in the coastal zone, it will need a local coastal plan amendment and a coastal development permit, both of which fall under the purview of the California Coastal Commission, meaning a lengthy process awaits. Public Works Director Brian Gerving said staff is currently working to finish environmental documentation for the project, including an archeological survey, and will then look to develop a site plan by mid-August. Following that, the city will host a meeting to gather neighborhood input, followed by local coastal amendment and coastal development permit processes with the coastal commission. All told, Gerving said the city hopes construction can begin next spring.
By some indications, it can't open soon enough. As if to underscore the need for creative housing solutions like Chinn's PG&E village, the Humboldt County Grand Jury issued a report July 2 titled "Like Home? There's No Place ..." that assessed housing issues in Humboldt County. Unsurprsingly, the report found that Humboldt County has a disproportionately high homeless population that far exceeds available shelter space, that there are a lack of transitional housing options and an entrenched lack of affordable housing. Further, the report states, new construction of affordable housing units is moving at a snail's pace, as we've previously reported ("Draft Housing Element Calls for Drastic Solutions to Humboldt's Housing 'Crisis,'" May 23).
"The production rate of affordable housing units is insufficient to meet the needs of the county's residents and homeless," reads one of the report's findings.
The report makes a wide variety of recommendations, including that the city and county direct staff to look at providing financial incentives for people who build accessory dwelling units to help meet housing demand (something that has been done successfully in other areas of California) and that the county move forward with some of the bold recommendations contained in the draft housing element update. This included the creation of a tiny house village and a sanctioned area for people to sleep in their cars.
Plans for Chinn's transitional housing project have each of the 11 trailers being converted into a duplex and they could combine to house 24 individuals and six families. While that number pales in comparison to the almost 1,500 people estimated to be living without shelter in Humboldt County, the grand jury report and the county's housing element update have made clear there is no silver-bullet project that will alleviate the area's housing crisis. Rather, experts agree, it will take a multi-faceted approach.
Meanwhile, Chinn continues to see results with her Blue Angel Village, which launched in partnership with the Humboldt Coalition for Property Rights as the city of Eureka was clearing the PalCo Marsh of the city's largest and most entrenched homeless encampments. While the project, initially located at Third and Commercial streets in Eureka, met fierce backlash from neighboring business owners, it quickly earned their overall buy-in. In addition to operating without major incident, the project served more than 500 clients in its first two years, helping 442 of them find jobs and moving 229 into permanent housing.
The project has since moved to a city-owned lot on Koster Street, where it similarly met some initial neighborhood skepticism but seems to have run smoothly.
Chinn said she's excited that plans for the village on the Crowley property seem to be moving forward. She said she already has the funding she needs to get started, thanks to contributions from the county, the city and St. Joseph Hospital. Because the goal is to help people build up rental histories before moving into permanent housing, Chinn said the project will only charge minimal rent — essentially enough to cover PG&E bills and insurance — allowing people to save money for future deposits. New residents will be set up with case management and whatever services they need, she said, with the goal of reducing those as their stays progress before they ultimately move out on their own.
"I think it'll be good for the people," she said.
July 4, 2019
North Coast Journal
By Thadeus Greenson


Friday, August 16, 2019

[Santa Clara County] Grand jury report blasts VTA for inefficiencies, poor oversight

Report: 'A case can be made for dismantling or phasing out the light rail system altogether'


The Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority, which runs the county's light rail and public buses, came under fire in a new Santa Clara County Civil Grand Jury report that called it one of the most inefficient transit agencies in the country. The taxpayer-funded agency in charge of offering transit solutions to Santa Clara County's traffic jams is currently embroiled in a mess of its own.
The Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority (VTA), the multi-billion dollar agency that plans and operates the county's road and transit network, has been called out as one of the most inefficient organizations of its kind.
A new county Civil Grand Jury report released last month found that VTA is spending more and accomplishing less than nearly every other comparable transit agency in the United States.
Just over the last decade, the cost of running VTA's buses and light rail system has nearly doubled, mainly due to labor costs. Meanwhile, fewer riders appear to be using VTA transit services than they have in the last 30 years. Ridership on bus and light rail has dropped nearly 20% just over the last decade. Taken altogether, this means VTA is losing about $9.30 per rider, according to the report.
The grand jury report lays much of the responsibility for this dysfunction on the VTA Board of Directors. The 12-member governing board consists entirely of political appointees who must be currently serving as city council members or on the Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors. Often, board members face a steep learning curve, and it doesn't help that they often lack any experience in transportation, finance or management of an agency of this size, the report says.
What results is that VTA board members quickly become overwhelmed with their duties, which include reading through board packets hundreds of pages long. It becomes too difficult to govern the transit agency in addition to the communities they were elected to serve, so VTA board members tend to focus their attention on their own communities instead of VTA. VTA reports generally go unread, and board members tend to make decisions to benefit their own constituents, that are not in the interests of the county as a whole, the report maintains.
After reading the grand jury report, Mountain View Councilman John McAlister described it as "all true, and it's long overdue." For about two years, McAlister has represented Mountain View, Palo Alto, Los Altos and Los Altos Hills on the VTA board. In that time, he says he has been disappointed by the lack of interest and engagement by some of his colleagues. There doesn't seem to be any political will to correct the problems, he said.
"Some board members are there because their mayor planted them, or they're there to pad their resume," he said. "There's no true continuity on the board, and then there's no feeling of responsibility because you have this continual change of characters."
The grand jury report echoes a common complaint from North County city leaders who say that San Jose exerts outsized influence on the VTA board. San Jose is allocated five board seats, while another five are split between the other 14 cities in the county. The county Board of Supervisors receives two seats.
In part, the report blames this dominance by San Jose political interests for the problems with the county's underperforming light rail system. The light rail line extends more than 42 miles, running from Mountain View south through much of San Jose, yet it has failed to link to many obvious destinations such as jobs centers, shopping districts or the San Jose International Airport. Taken on its own, the light rail costs taxpayers about $11 in subsidies for each passenger who uses it, costing about three times more than bus transit.
"A case can be made for dismantling or phasing out the light rail system altogether," the grand jury report noted. "A large reduction in the taxpayer subsidy of VTA operations could be achieved by focusing future investment in transit solutions other than light rail."
However, the VTA board actually seems to favor doubling down on light rail and expanding the service. The transit agency is currently considering a pair of light rail extensions to bring it to the Eastridge shopping center in San Jose and near the Netflix headquarters in Los Gatos. The 2.4-mile Eastridge extension will cost $453 million to complete ($146 million has already been spent). If built, it is expected to generate a net total of 611 new riders.
At a meeting on June 6, the VTA board voted unanimously to approve the final environmental impact report for the Eastridge extension, one of the last steps before the project moves forward. San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo, who sits on the VTA board, acknowledged the project doesn't make sense unless its usage wildly exceeds its projections.
"It's not because of the ridership today, because the ridership today doesn't support this kind of investment," Liccardo said. "But what we see happening in the city in terms of opportunity is an incredibly vibrant corridor. If we can get this right, this transit system will be at the core of that."
According to the grand jury report, the case for expanding light rail is weak and is based entirely on political pressure. The authors of the report say they found "virtually no support" for the Eastridge expansion among VTA staff, and the project seemed to be happening solely to satisfy goals in Measure A on the 2000 ballot.
The best way to fix VTA administration would be to change its governance, the report concluded. Having fewer members, but giving them longer office terms would give the board more expertise and institutional knowledge. The report also recommends directly electing board members to their seats, rather than having them appointed.
The VTA board is starting to investigate this possibility. McAlister is leading a new board enhancement committee tasked with restructuring VTA governance. The committee has only convened one meeting so far, but it eventually will deliver some kind of recommendations back to the full board.
"My gut preferences would be to make VTA an independent board not made up of elected officials," McAlister said. "But I don't want to rush it. It's like the Mueller report. I want to take the time to get it right."
The VTA board has not yet commented on the findings in the civil grand jury report, but it is required by law to issue a formal response within 90 days. In a blog entry, VTA board chairwoman Teresa O'Neill, a councilwoman from Santa Clara, could only say that the report's recommendations would be investigated.
"We intend to carefully review the report provided by the Civil Grand Jury," she wrote. "The report will help to inform the work we are currently performing."
July 4, 2019
Palo Alto Online
By Mark Noack, Mountain View Voice


Humboldt County grand jury highlights deadlock on homelessness

Report spotlights affordable housing need, offers short-, long-term fixes


In order to solve the homeless crisis in Humboldt County the area needs to prioritize a Housing First approach that provides immediate shelter to stabilize the homeless for transition into permanent housing, according to the 2018 Humboldt County Civil Grand Jury report on homelessness released Tuesday. The caveat: Humboldt County, which recorded 1,473 unsheltered homeless during the 2019 Department of Housing and Urban Development Point-In-Time (PIT) count in January, lacks an “adequate stock” of affordable housing necessary to accomplish this solution. It states an additional 3,390 housing units must be built to meet anticipated housing demands through 2027 which “alone requires building an average of 170 units annually.”
“While creating more usable shelter is necessary, speeding up the rate at which affordable housing is generated will go a long way to address the homeless crisis,” the report notes, citing one of the primary recommendations offered by the consulting firm charged with studying this countywide problem, Focus Strategies.
The hard reality of the region’s shelter shortage, reported in a city homelessness assessment in August 2014, prompted Eureka and Humboldt County to hire Focus and jointly adopt the Housing First model in 2016, leading to the formation of the Homeless Strategy and Implementation Plan — a collaborative effort between the city and county to apply Housing First.
Since then little has been done by way of building those structures which could offer the kind of long-term care and support the homeless — many of whom are dealing with mental health issues, substance abuse problems and disability — need.
“Progress is hampered by a split” in the Housing Trust Fund and Homelessness Solutions Committee, the report reads.
Formed by the county Board of Supervisors, the trust fund committee, which began meeting in June 2018 as part of the implementation plan, is deadlocked on how best to tackle homelessness. The group is divided over whether a turn toward short-term solutions — such as safe parking programs for those who wish to take shelter in their cars, sanctioned camping areas or tiny home villages — or the implementation of building structures will best meet Housing First principles.
There is meanwhile no “ongoing funding source” for the purposes of building affordable housing projects nor is there any money available in the trust fund, the report reads. Possible as-yet untapped resources, according to the report, include state and federal grants, local financial institutions, local jurisdictions, sale of surplus county property, the county’s General Fund, private foundations and individuals.
The report offered a list of recommendations, noting that cities such as Las Vegas and Los Angeles “have found it necessary to create temporary shelter despite their commitment to Housing First.”
The document acknowledges that “while short-term solutions have drawbacks, there are segments of our homeless population that would be best served by implementing one or more of these short-term strategies, closely managed to ensure the well-being of guests and assuage public concerns.”
With proper screening and supervision, temporary shelter provides participants the safety and stability required for finding permanent housing.
The Focus firm’s stated issue with short-term solutions such as sanctioned encampments, however, is that they pull resources from affordable housing projects and thus the primary aim of establishing Housing First. In addition, they “have little impact on reducing homelessness.”
Finding a location for short-term solutions is also an obstacle, the report states, in light of “NIMBYism”: “an acronym for those not wanting an impact they consider unpleasant near their property (Not-In-My-Back-Yard-ism).”
To address this, the report highlighted the benefits of mobilizing the community through dialogue and education. It cited the Betty Kwan Chinn Homeless Foundation’s Blue Angel Village and the Eureka Rescue Mission (the Mission) as cases where the community impact has been “minimal.”
Other recommendations include:
• “(removing) barriers to using existing shelters” such as pet, partner and possession restrictions;
• “(expanding) existing models” such as the Mission, Arcata House Partnership, the Betty Kwan Chinn Foundation and Redwood Community Action Agency/Youth Services Bureau, each of which are dealing with limited resources;
• “(repurposing) existing structures for shelter” by making them compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act;
• “(generating) affordable housing more quickly” by encouraging individual property owners to build affordable housing (what are called “accessory dwelling units” as well as tiny houses) through the use of county loans and permit-ready building plans and also by rehabilitating existing properties such as defunct hotels into affordable housing units.
The Homeless Strategy and Implementation Plan finally offered four “key strategies,” according to the report:
• adopt a countywide Housing First approach;
• “strengthen and reorient” the county Department of Health and Human Services Mobile Intervention and Services Team (MIST), which connects the chronically homeless with services for substance abuse, mental illness and housing through “ride-alongs” with the Eureka Police Department;
• “create direct and low-barrier pathways to housing” including “rental subsidies with supportive services available to help transition homeless people into rental properties,” “housing interventions” (“rapid rehousing,” “shelter diversion,” “interim housing” and “permanent supportive housing”), “landlord outreach” and social services to support housing stability;
• and the use of data systems to “track progress” in the homeless outreach programs.
Funds are available through state and federal agencies that offer grant money to address immediate and long-term housing needs but the City of Eureka, which “bears the brunt of the homeless population” while lacking the “independent funding and resources” necessary to confront the issue head-on, is beholden to the county government, “creating tension between the two.” Hence the implementation plan’s recommendation for increased cooperation between them.
Betty Kwan Chinn, director of her namesake homeless foundation, echoed the report’s findings.
“Everybody wants to do it, to help out, but we are so limited,” she said. “We need more housing.”
Part of the solution, added Chinn, whose various housing initiatives have required public relations campaigns, is a matter of shifting public perception about homelessness — particularly in light of the NIMBYism cited in the report.
“Some people, you just need to let them know what’s happened,” she said, referring to the necessity of educating the community about issues related to homelessness: age, disability, mental illness among them.
The Rev. Eric Duff, past president of Arcata House and former chair of the bygone Humboldt County Task Force on Homelessness and Housing, said the lack of affordable housing has been an issue for the last 30 years.
When asked about appropriate measures to address the problem he turned to Chinn as a model.
“We need to do like Betty’s doing — start from the ground up and build,” he said, acknowledging that there needs to be a both-and approach to Housing First which involves providing immediate, unrestricted shelter to stabilize the homeless and permanent housing projects.
Edie Jessup, who served on the board of Affordable Homeless and Homeless Alternatives, a homeless advocacy coalition in the county, said city and county officials need to nuance their understanding of Housing First.
“I think that Housing First and the way it’s been interpreted in Humboldt County is really a mistake,” Jessup said. “And that getting people stabilized, even if it’s in a temporary and not-full-on permanent housing way, is critical. And then when the housing’s developed, that’s terrific, people can move into it. But leaving people out is really just horrible … .”
Jessup added that the criminalization of homelessness just exacerbates the crisis. The disbanding of encampments such as the one at the Palco Marsh creates a kind of community-wide instability among the homeless and wastes valuable assets that could go into providing onsite services for the unsheltered, she said.
“It’s really cruel and we don’t have to do it that way,” Jessup said of breaking up short-term housing solutions like sanctioned encampments. “We could do it another way. It means taking a whole different attitude about who are neighbors are … .”
The grand jury has requested a response to its report from the Humboldt County Board of Supervisors and the Eureka City Council.
July 4, 2019
Eureka Times Standard
By Robert Peach


Thursday, August 15, 2019

[Madera County] Residents speak out, after Madera County Grand Jury report details alleged wrongdoing by city staff

“We have our own fireworks here, and we don’t need a, have to, light a match,” Madera resident Ron Montoya said.
Just one day before the Fourth of July, those fireworks briefly exploding inside Wednesday night’s Madera City Council meeting.
“One change that hasn’t been made, is removing our mayor,” Madera landlord and part-time resident Khalid Chaudhry said.
This just days, after the Madera County Grand Jury report accused the city of malfeasance, dodging inquiries, lying, even blocking requests for documents, and conflicts of interests, possibly breaking California government code.
“It was speechless, it kind of, I felt like throwing up, this is our government,” Chaudhry said.
The investigation started, looking into a speculated tie between salary increases of some department heads and increased water rates.
It found the city has no code of ethics, and some administrators and elected officials are doing personal business with the city, as private individuals.
“It was nice to hear that people are watching, listening, and there’s eyes and ears for people like myself,” Montoya said. “And future residents who want to come up here and have a voice.”
The report also claiming the grand jury had to send cease and desist orders, after some violated the jury’s admonition of secrecy.
City of Madera Communications Specialist Joseph Carrello says, the city will be issuing an official response.
“We have 60 days to do so,” Carrello said. “We need to dig through all the facts, and we’re going to speak to what they’ve said.”
The report made many recommendations for the city, from this point on, including agendas written in terms easier for the public to understand.
The Madera County District Attorney is also looking into the report, to see if any criminal charges could come of it.
July 3, 2019
YourCentralValley.com
By Megan Rupe


[San Bernardino County] Upland’s revenues grow, outpacing increased pension costs

The new budget includes $41.9 million in general fund spending and $42.9 million in anticipated operating revenue.


Six years after a former official warned the city of Upland was in danger of going bankrupt, it is now in the black, even as its pension obligations continue to grow.
News of the city’s improved financial footing comes as the San Bernardino County Grand Jury urges Upland to get serious about tackling its unfunded pension obligations, which continue to grow.
On June 24, the Upland City Council approved the budget for the current fiscal year, which began July 1. Although the budget shows pension obligation costs rising, it also suggests that the wolf is not yet at the door.
The new budget includes $41.9 million in general fund spending. That’s up $1 million over the year before, including an additional $546,830 in pension increases and salaries, and an increase of $460,160 in maintenance and operations.
But revenue is going up even faster, with $42.9 million in anticipated operating revenue. That’s up $1.73 million over the year before, including an additional $727,420 in property taxes thanks to an increase in assessed values and property sales.
“I first noticed the city finances were improved for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2016,” Councilwoman Janice Elliott said Wednesday. Since her election, the city has contracted with the county for fire protection services, replaced full-time employees with contractors and delayed infrastructure maintenance to cut costs.
“That’s going to make things look rosy, but they don’t make things disappear,” Elliott said. “You’re actually going to spend more money when you finally catch up on repairs.”
But the city’s pension debt is growing as well. The new budget pegs Upland’s unfunded pension liability at $38,350, up from $33,760 in the previous year.
The California Public Employee Retirement System represents 1.9 million public employees. Cities throughout the state are struggling to keep up with payments to the retirement system, which has been burdened in part by employees with CalPERS pensions living longer lives, requiring more money than was previously anticipated to continue paying their pensions.
According to Stanford University’s Institute for Economic Policy Research, government agencies statewide may owe more than $1 trillion to CalPERS, depending on investment returns. According to Stanford’s PensionTracker.org website, each Upland household is responsible for $13,072 in unfunded pension debt from the city of Upland and $186 in unfunded debt from the Upland City Housing Authority.
It could be worse, though: According to the same site, the average California household is responsible for $78,334 in unfunded pension debt. Montclair plans to dip into its reserves to cover its unfunded pension liabilities for the coming year.
In its report, the Grand Jury gave Upland an Aug. 27 deadline to respond to its request for an explicit plan to deal with its unfunded pension obligations.
“Although we haven’t passed a policy on it, we have contributed a significant amount of money to an account that is solely dedicated to paying for the pension,” Elliott said.
Interim City Manager Rosemary Hoerning did not respond to requests for comment.
July 3, 2019
Inland Valley Daily Bulletin
By Beau Yarbrough


Santa Barbara County grand jury says Cachuma Project needs entirely new contract

Santa Barbara County Water Agency should seek a completely new contract with the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation rather than simply renewing the 1995 Cachuma Project contract in 2020, a grand jury found during an investigation into the contract process.
Grand jurors came up with nine findings and recommendations for resolving each of those findings.
Cachuma Project agencies required to respond to the findings and recommendations are the County Water Agency, the County Board of Superivsors, the city of Santa Barbara, the Carpinteria Valley, Goleta and Montecito water districts and the Santa Ynez River Water Conservation District Improvement District No. 1.
The agencies have 90 days from the June 28 release date to respond.
One of the findings said the current contract “does not fully address future water management problems such as will arise from climate and other rapid environmental changes.”
Jurors recommended the County Board of Supervisors, acting as directors of the County Water Agency, propose the new Cachuma Project contract require a public meeting with the Bureau of Reclamation every five years to consider changing provisions that have become outdated.
But the grand jury report went beyond recommending a new contract be negotiated every five years.
Jurors said the County Water Agency and five districts that distribute Cachuma Lake water should stop squabbling and speak with one voice when dealing with the Bureau of Reclamation, especially regarding the amount of water to be diverted to the districts each year.
“Regular meetings of their technical staffs could alleviate disagreements,” Rande Downer, grand jury foreperson, said in announcing the release of the report.
The report noted that under the 1995 contract, meetings between the agencies that are required every five years can’t result in increased water diversions to member units.
It recommended allowing the meetings to lead to increased diversions as long as they are consistent with federal and state laws and project water rights and don’t have a negative effect on the environment or downstream groundwater quality.
Jurors said using a “water year” starting Oct. 1 and ending Sept. 30 makes it difficult to make decisions, particularly on water diversions, because the period ends right before the rainy season begins and it's hard to predict how much water will be available in the lake over the next few months.
They recommended creating a “water year” from May 1 to April 30, or a similar period, so water diversion requests are made soon after the rainy season ends.
Another of the findings said the Water Agency and Cachuma Project member units agree technical staff meetings are valuable, but they disagree over organizational concerns raised over previous meetings.
The report recommends the Water Agency and member units set a schedule of key technical staff meetings each year to discuss project operations and report areas of agreement and disagreement to their respective boards.
Grand jurors said their investigation initially focused on the renewal of the 1995 contract, due in 2020, but they soon found parts of the contract are ambiguous.
“The Jury sought project records to educate itself on these matters,” the report said. “Most of the search was online: It was not expected to be difficult and could show how easily citizens with an active interest in water issues, or candidates for a water district board, could find information they needed.
“The search revealed two problems,” the report continued. “Terminology was unclear in both the 1949 and 1995 contracts and in other related documents, and local websites provide little access to detailed information about the project.”
Grand jurors said that in some cases, various terms are used interchangeably, and in other cases, the same term means different things.
As a result, the grand jury said directors of the Cachuma Project’s member units, along with the County Water Agency, should require key terms to be clearly defined and consistently used in the new contract.
Jurors also said the Water Agency and member units should “set up and maintain a specific website for detailed information on the Cachuma Project's history, structure, governance and operations, with links to additional historical documents and records.”
July 3, 2019
Lompoc Record and Santa Ynez Valley News
By Mike Hodgson